It's Not Defiance: Understanding and Supporting Children with Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA)
By: Nikki Lee
What Is Pathological Demand Avoidance?
Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA) is not an official diagnosis in the DSM-5, but it’s a pattern of behavior seen in some children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) or ADHD. Kids with PDA often appear “defiant,” but this behavior usually comes from anxiety, stress, and feeling out of control.
Common Signs of PDA in Children
Ongoing resistance to everyday demands at home, school, and in activities
Using creative ways to avoid requests (often misunderstood as "manipulative")
A strong need for control, independence, and routine
Avoidance of even fun activities if they feel pressured
Big emotional reactions when feeling overwhelmed
These behaviors aren't about being "bad" — they're about a child trying to protect their sense of safety and autonomy.
Why Traditional Discipline Doesn't Work
Children with PDA often struggle in high-demand environments like schools. When adults respond with stricter rules or consequences, the child’s anxiety usually grows, leading to more outbursts. This cycle can be very tough on caregivers, who may feel helpless or judged.
How to Support a Child with PDA
1. Understand the Root Cause
Children with PDA aren’t choosing to act out. Their behavior is a response to anxiety and nervous system overload. Before reacting, take a moment to pause and ask yourself, “What is my child trying to tell me through this behavior?”
Stay calm, regulate your own emotions, and focus on connection.
2. Avoid Labels Like "Defiant" or "Bad"
Labels like "naughty" or "oppositional" can be harmful. These words can shape how a child sees themselves and hurt their self-esteem. Instead of saying “You’re being bad,” try:
“It seems like something’s really hard for you right now. Let’s figure it out together.”
3. Teach Emotional Regulation Gently
Children need help recognizing and naming their feelings. When you stay calm and listen, they learn how to do the same. Be validating:
“I can see you’re frustrated. That’s okay. I’m here with you.”
Avoid shutting down their emotions, even if the behavior is challenging.
4. Use Collaboration Instead of Commands
Reduce pressure and build in choices. Let them feel in control. Try phrases like:
“Would you be okay with…?”
“What do you think would work best?”
“We can figure this out together.”
This helps build trust and encourages important life skills like communication and problem-solving.
5. Spend Time in Their World
Children need non-demanding time where they’re in charge. Let them lead playtime. Follow their interests. This builds connection and helps lower anxiety.
Play is more than fun—it’s how they process emotions and build confidence.
6. Create a Supportive Environment
Help teachers and caregivers understand PDA. Advocate for your child’s needs. A flexible, low-demand setting can make a huge difference in their emotional safety and success.
Supporting a child with Pathological Demand Avoidance takes patience and compassion.
With the right tools and understanding, you can help them feel safer, more in control, and better able to express themselves.
You are not alone—and neither is your child.
Resources
If you or someone you know is struggling with their mental health, help is available! Give us a call today at 217-203-2008 to start promoting peace from within.